Publication Account
Date 2007
Event ID 587560
Category Descriptive Accounts
Type Publication Account
Permalink http://canmore.org.uk/event/587560
NS69 1 COLDOCH
NS/6963 9812 (GPS – NS/69652 98129)
This probable solid-based broch or broch-like dun in Kincardine stands on a slight rise immediately next to the flat land of the Forth Valley – originally an extensive marsh. The broch was cleared out just before 1870 and a plan prepared [2]; apparently a report on the excavation was expected but never materialized: “A notice of this broch, with plans, will be in the Society’s Transactions, the Archaeologia Scotica, vol. V.” [2, 38, footnote). There is nothing in the journal mentioned. The entrance passage, the inner wallface and the various intra-mural features are still exposed but the site is difficult to assess now, being usually overgrown with turf and weeds. The author has some photographs of internal features but they show very little and are not included here.
Graham [4] was the first to describe the site again in modern times, giving the diameter of the central court as from 8.39 - 9.00m (27 ft 6 ins to 29 ft 6 ins), within a wall from 5.34 - 5.95m (17 ft 6 ins to 19 ft 6 ins) thick. The wall is of poor-quality masonry of smallish stones and the core stands to a maximum height of 2.44m (8 ft); the inner wallface is about 1.22m (4 ft) high. There are three mural chambers and a stairway within the wall, while the entrance is on the east side. The poor quality of the masonry is the reason for doubting that this structure could ever have been a broch tower, though in every other way the ground plan is typical.
The unusually narrow entrance passage is about 5.80m (19 ft) long and faces just north of east; it is 0.71m (2 ft 4 in) wide at its outer end and only 59cm (1 ft 11 in) at the inner. The door-frame is about 2.14m (7 ft) from the exterior and the two checks – one of which is broken – are apparently of upright stone slabs. The bar-hole is on the right (north) of the passage and was apparently 2.14m (7 ft) deep at the time of the excavation [4, 13]. The bar-socket – now obscured because of displacement of the stonework – was apparently 61cm (2 ft) then. The passage widens to 1.22m (4 ft) behind the door-frame. There is no guard cell.
The other intra-mural features consist of the doorway to the intra-mural stair at 7 o’clock and doors to cells at 10, 1 and 3 o’clock. There were also two small recesses or aumbries about 20cm (8 in) square in the inner wallface between 7 and 8 o’clock (see Torwood – NS88 1).
The doorway to the stair is 69cm (2 ft 3 in) wide at its inner end and widens slightly towards the stair lobby; there is only a very slight recess instead of a stair-foot guard cell (see Buchlyvie – NS59 2). Now roofless the doorway appears to have still been lintelled in 1870 [4, 14, f.n. 1]. The stairway is 81cm (2 ft 8 in) wide and runs out on to the present wallhead; seven steps remained in 1870.
The three intra-mural cells are approximately rectangular in shape, the one at 10 o’clock having one curved and one straight end; the doorway to that at 4 o’clock is blocked. The doorway to the cell at 1 o’clock was still lintelled in 1949 [4, Pl. III.3]. The lengths of the three cells (starting at 10 o’clock) are – 2.62m (8 ft 7 in), 2.44m (8 ft 0 in) and 2.59m (8 ft 6 in). The rectangular shape of the cell at 4 o’clock is very marked but not far above the floor the corners become curved at the upper part is oval; in 1870 this cell had a complete roof with a ‘beehive’ corbelled structure.
Finds: fragments of whalebones are reported to have been found inside this broch (the author clearly remembers reading about this many years ago but has been unable to track down the source); such are known from the blue marine clay which indicates that the Forth valley was once a shallow estuary of the sea in much earlier times. Whales were doubtless occasionally stranded in the shallow water and the bones found when the estuary became a marsh in pre-Iron Age times. Coldoch broch is close to the old estuary.
Dimensions: diameter of central court 8.39 - 9.00m (29 ft 6in to 27 ft 6 in), wall thickness from 5.34 - 5.95m (17 ft 6 in and 19 ft 6 in): the wall proportion is approx. 56.5%.
Sources: 1. NMRS site no. NS 69 NE 6: 2. MacLaglan 1872, 37-9: 3. Anderson 1877, 324 and fig.: 4. Graham 1949, 12-14: 5. RCAHMS 1979b, no. 151: 6. McInnes 1985: 7. Armit 2003, 125.
E W MacKie 2007
