Field Visit

Date 15 June 1927

Event ID 1098425

Category Recording

Type Field Visit

Permalink http://canmore.org.uk/event/1098425

RCAHMS County Inventory: Fife, Kinross and Clackmannan

Balcomie Castle.

Out on Fife Ness, within half a mile of the shore, are the remains of a large mansion of the later 16th century, to which a modern house with offices and farmsteading has been attached. The old building formed the southern side of a courtyard and was apparently laid out on a symmetrical plan, having a main block lying east and west, with a wing projecting from each of the southern corners. The western wing contained a turret- stair corbelled out within the eastern re-entrantangle. But the principal staircase has been a turnpike projecting externally from the north wall of the main block, and the main entrance probably lay at the stair-foot. Subsequently, however, a projection containing a doorway was formed at the north end of the east gable of the main block, and an outbuilding was runout northwards as far as the gatehouse, which stood at the eastern end of the enclosure. Of this extension no traces remain except a vaulted chamber with an upper floor immediately south of the gatehouse. In a still later alteration the space between the wings on the southern side of the house was filled up with a low, vaulted structure. Only the west wing and the western part of the main block are complete, the other parts being too fragmentary to admit of description.

The main block has been four storeys in height, while the west wing has had five floors, the upper one in each being coom-ceiled and lit by semi-dormers. The masonry is of coursed rubble. The window margins are moulded, and in some of the breasts are gun-loops. The southern angles of the wing are provided with two-storeyed turrets, now truncated, carried on a slightly projecting encorbellment of three structural members, as against five in the encorbellment of the stair-turret. The ground floor has been vaulted and the vaults still stand in the chambers of the wings and in the surviving western chamber of the main block. On the first floor the hall occupied the missing eastern part of the main block, but only one jamb of its fireplace and a jamb of the dais window are left. What remains has been an inner chamber, now almost entirely filled by a modern brick erection. In its east and north walls are mural chambers, and windows look to south and west. The wing chamber lies ensuite. Its fireplace has at some time been moved to the south-west angle from its original position in the south wall, where a window has been inserted. The western window has been altered and a press inserted beside it. In the north wall is a close garderobe, and at the north-east angle is the entrance to the turret-stair, which ascends to the floor above, for that storey, unlike the others, could not be entered directly from the main block. The three upper floors of the wing are similar in arrangement to the first floor and it will be remarked that the family apartments were thus grouped at one end of the house.

The gatehouse (Fig. 149) has been altered, and a modern building is now attached to it. The masonry is of ashlar, laid in 11-inch courses. In the lower part is a transe with loop-holes on each side. This has originally consisted of two divisions, separated by an archway and both vaulted, the outer vault being at the level of the outer archway, while the inner vault and archway have been lower. The vaults and the inner arches have subsequently been removed and windows inserted to west and south. In the north spandrel of the outer arch is a sundial, and above the arch are three armorial panels within moulded margins. The central panel, which appears to have been an insertion of a date later than those on either side, bears on a label SANS FEINTISE, and for crest two clasped hands; the helm is mantled and wreathed, the shield, held by two men, bears: Quarterly, 1st and 4th, on a chevron three mascles (for Learmonth), 2nd and 3rd, on a bend three roses (for Dairsie), the whole for Learmonth of Balcomie. At the bottom of the panel is a label apparently dated A.D. 1602. The dexter panel bears a scroll with the motto, SANS FEINTISE. The shield, having a charge similar to that in the centre, is contained within an encircling garland, and beneath it are the initials [J].L. for [James] Learmonth. The sinister panel bears at the top the motto, ADVYSEDLIE. The shield enclosed by a garland is charged with a chevron between three roundels, for Myrton (Myrtoun); below are the initials E.M. for Elizabeth Myrton, daughter of David Myrton of Randerston (1). Above the grouped panels is the inscription: [EXCEPT] THE . LORD. BVILD . THE. HOVSE . THEY. LABOVR . IN . VAINE . THAT . BVILD . IT. On the north side of the transe is a vaulted porter's-room with an upper chamber, which is reached from a forestair and provided with a fireplace and close garderobe. The chamber above the transe has been considerably altered. Within the courtyard is a draw-well.

GARDEN ENTRANCE. A walled garden or orchard lies south-east of the castle enclosure. The entrance, dating from the late 16th or early 17th century, has a moulded margin quirked upward in the centre of the lintel to enclose a grotesque mask.

DOVECOT. There is a roofless and probably late dovecot beside the smithy at Hollowflat, 600 yards south-south-east of the castle. It is almost square on plan, measuring 16 by 16 ¾ feet. The nests have probably been of wood.

HISTORICAL NOTE. James Learmonth of Clatto had a grant from the King of the lands of Balcomie in feu-farm in 1526. Part of the reddendo was the building of a mansion (2). Eleven years later, the King confirmed a charter by his secretary, Sir Thomas Erskine, now the superior of these lands, to James Learmonth of Dairsie, who had bought the lands of Balcomie, and the charter included power to build ‘folds’ for the keeping of beasts and goods (3). A later Sir James Learmonth of Balcomie perished in 1598 as one of the Fife Adventurers in Lewis (4), and the estate passed to his brother Sir John Learmonth of Birkhill. It is therefore the arms of Sir John that appear on the panel dated 1602. His son, Sir James, was President of the Court of Session in 1643 and 1647. Robert, son of Sir James, died without issue, and the property passed to his nephew, William Gordon, advocate, of the solicitor to James VII (5).

RCAHMS 1933, visited 15 June 1927.

(1) East Neuk of Fife, p. 444. (2) Reg. Mag.Sig., s.a., No. 393. (3) Ibid., No. 1710. (4) Autobiography and Diary of James Melville (Wodrow Society), p. 126. (5) Cf. Laing Charters, No.2960. Cf. also Cast. and Dom. Arch., ii, p. 355.