Loch Doon, Donald's Isle

NX49NE 1 4943 9655

'An island in Loch Doon. This island perpetuates the name of a dreamy ascetic the foundation course of whose habitation is still above ground. Tradition has it that Donald's bones lie bleaching in the water that encircled him in life. Donald's notorious weakness for a less gentle liquid is still deplored in the neighbourhood.'

OS Name Book 1858.

(NX 4941 9655). Structures formerly known as 'Monks Graves' (J Smith) on Donald's Isle formerly Isle Donan (T Pont 1596) were excavated in 1933-36 in the belief that they might prove to be the remains of an early monastic establishment. All the evidence however points to this having been a medieval domestic site, possibly a 13th-14th c timber hall-house (A E Truckell and J Williams 1967) (cf NX54NE 6).

The island itself, now submerged but periodically exposed, is of granite blocks and debris. The main structure on the island was a rectangular boulder foundation, 43' by 12'4, within walls c 8' thick with a single entrance in the west wall. Attached to this on the north was a secondary walled structure, with beyond it evidence of a timber building in the form of a horse-shoe setting of stones and many flat-headed iron nails. To the south of the main structure were the remains of an elongated hut formed of boulders. A setting of stones, apparently springing from the NW corner of the main structure, enclosed the complex except on the SW. Outside this on the west was a boat jetty.

A 1260 coin was recovered from the infill of the hut and much medieval pottery was found. Early occupation of the site is indicated by the finding of flints at the old surface level, these probably being comparable with worked and unworked flints of Mesolithic aspect found on the island in 1969 (Proc Soc Antiq Scot 1881). A segment of 1st-2nd century AD (H E Kilbride-Jones 1938) glass armlet was found in the infill of the main structure.

The objects from the excavation and others found previously are in the NMAS (Acc Nos HT 6-9, BG 390, FJ 144, AB 2619-26 MEA 12).

OS 6" map (1856); A Fairbairn 1937; M L Ansell 1969.

NX 4943 9655. At present the level of Loch Doon is abnormally low and although Donald's Isle itself is not visible the remains of a rectangular building 15.0m NS by 5.0m with another building 5.0m square to the S can be seen from the shore.

Visited by OS (BS) 2 June 1976

Two unroofed buildings are depicted on the 1st edition of the OS 6-inch map (Ayrshire 1859, sheet lix), but they are not shown on the current edition of the OS 1:10000 map (1978).

The creation of Loch Doon Reservoir (NX49NE 20) caused a rise in the water level, and this site is now under water.

Information from RCAHMS (SAH), 11 February 2000.